Purdue University Graduate School
Emerson_Thesis_20190716.pdf (15.86 MB)


Download (15.86 MB)
posted on 2019-10-16, 16:26 authored by David Ross EmersonDavid Ross Emerson
Depth estimation is increasingly becoming more important in computer vision. The requirement for autonomous systems to gauge their surroundings is of the utmost importance in order to avoid obstacles, preventing damage to itself and/or other systems or people. Depth measuring/estimation systems that use multiple cameras from multiple views can be expensive and extremely complex. And as these autonomous systems decrease in size and available power, the supporting sensors required to estimate depth must also shrink in size and power consumption.

This research will concentrate on a single passive method known as Depth from Defocus (DfD), which uses an in-focus and out-of-focus image to infer the depth of objects in a scene. The major contribution of this research is the introduction of a new Deep Learning (DL) architecture to process the the in-focus and out-of-focus images to produce a depth map for the scene improving both speed and performance over a range of lighting conditions. Compared to the previous state-of-the-art multi-label graph cuts algorithms applied to the synthetically blurred dataset the DfD-Net produced a 34.30\% improvement in the average Normalized Root Mean Square Error (NRMSE). Similarly the DfD-Net architecture produced a 76.69\% improvement in the average Normalized Mean Absolute Error (NMAE). Only the Structural Similarity Index (SSIM) had a small average decrease of 2.68\% when compared to the graph cuts algorithm. This slight reduction in the SSIM value is a result of the SSIM metric penalizing images that appear to be noisy. In some instances the DfD-Net output is mottled, which is interpreted as noise by the SSIM metric.

This research introduces two methods of deep learning architecture optimization. The first method employs the use of a variant of the Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO) algorithm to improve the performance of the DfD-Net architecture. The PSO algorithm was able to find a combination of the number of convolutional filters, the size of the filters, the activation layers used, the use of a batch normalization layer between filters and the size of the input image used during training to produce a network architecture that resulted in an average NRMSE that was approximately 6.25\% better than the baseline DfD-Net average NRMSE. This optimized architecture also resulted in an average NMAE that was 5.25\% better than the baseline DfD-Net average NMAE. Only the SSIM metric did not see a gain in performance, dropping by 0.26\% when compared to the baseline DfD-Net average SSIM value.

The second method illustrates the use of a Self Organizing Map clustering method to reduce the number convolutional filters in the DfD-Net to reduce the overall run time of the architecture while still retaining the network performance exhibited prior to the reduction. This method produces a reduced DfD-Net architecture that has a run time decrease of between 14.91\% and 44.85\% depending on the hardware architecture that is running the network. The final reduced DfD-Net resulted in a network architecture that had an overall decrease in the average NRMSE value of approximately 3.4\% when compared to the baseline, unaltered DfD-Net, mean NRMSE value. The NMAE and the SSIM results for the reduced architecture were 0.65\% and 0.13\% below the baseline results respectively. This illustrates that reducing the network architecture complexity does not necessarily reduce the reduction in performance.

Finally, this research introduced a new, real world dataset that was captured using a camera and a voltage controlled microfluidic lens to capture the visual data and a 2-D scanning LIDAR to capture the ground truth data. The visual data consists of images captured at seven different exposure times and 17 discrete voltage steps per exposure time. The objects in this dataset were divided into four repeating scene patterns in which the same surfaces were used. These scenes were located between 1.5 and 2.5 meters from the camera and LIDAR. This was done so any of the deep learning algorithms tested would see the same texture at multiple depths and multiple blurs. The DfD-Net architecture was employed in two separate tests using the real world dataset.

The first test was the synthetic blurring of the real world dataset and assessing the performance of the DfD-Net trained on the Middlebury dataset. The results of the real world dataset for the scenes that were between 1.5 and 2.2 meters from the camera the DfD-Net trained on the Middlebury dataset produced an average NRMSE, NMAE and SSIM value that exceeded the test results of the DfD-Net tested on the Middlebury test set. The second test conducted was the training and testing solely on the real world dataset. Analysis of the camera and lens behavior led to an optimal lens voltage step configuration of 141 and 129. Using this configuration, training the DfD-Net resulted in an average NRMSE, NMAE and SSIM of 0.0660, 0.0517 and 0.8028 with a standard deviation of 0.0173, 0.0186 and 0.0641 respectively.


Degree Type

  • Doctor of Philosophy


  • Electrical and Computer Engineering

Campus location

  • Indianapolis

Advisor/Supervisor/Committee Chair

Dr. Lauren Christopher

Additional Committee Member 2

Dr. Zina Ben Miled

Additional Committee Member 3

Dr. Brian King

Additional Committee Member 4

Dr. Paul Salama