Purdue University Graduate School
Browse

ANALYSIS OF CONTINUOUS LEARNING MODELS FOR TRAJECTORY REPRESENTATION

Download (1.41 MB)
thesis
posted on 2023-04-24, 21:51 authored by Kendal Graham NormanKendal Graham Norman
<p> Trajectory planning is a field with widespread utility, and imitation learning pipelines<br> show promise as an accessible training method for trajectory planning. MPNet is the state<br> of the art for imitation learning with respect to success rates. MPNet has two general<br> components to its runtime: a neural network predicts the location of the next anchor point in<br> a trajectory, and then planning infrastructure applies sampling-based techniques to produce<br> near-optimal, collision-less paths. This distinction between the two parts of MPNet prompts<br> investigation into the role of the neural architectures in the Neural Motion Planning pipeline,<br> to discover where improvements can be made. This thesis seeks to explore the importance<br> of neural architecture choice by removing the planning structures, and comparing MPNet’s<br> feedforward anchor point predictor with that of a continuous model trained to output a<br> continuous trajectory from start to goal. A new state of the art model in continuous learning<br> is the Neural Flow model. As a continuous model, it possess a low standard deviation runtime<br> which can be properly leveraged in the absence of planning infrastructure. Neural Flows also<br> output smooth, continuous trajectory curves that serve to reduce noisy path outputs in the<br> absence of lazy vertex contraction. This project analyzes the performance of MPNet, Resnet<br> Flow, and Coupling Flow models when sampling-based planning tools such as dropout, lazy<br> vertex contraction, and replanning are removed. Each neural planner is trained end-to-end in<br> an imitation learning pipeline utilizing a simple feedforward encoder, a CNN-based encoder,<br> and a Pointnet encoder to encode the environment, for purposes of comparison. Results<br> indicate that performance is competitive, with Neural Flows slightly outperforming MPNet’s<br> success rates on our reduced dataset in Simple2D, and being slighty outperformed by MPNet<br> with respect to collision penetration distance in our UR5 Cubby test suite. These results<br> indicate that continuous models can compete with the performance of anchor point predictor<br> models when sampling-based planning techniques are not applied. Neural Flow models also<br> have other benefits that anchor point predictors do not, like continuity guarantees, the ability<br> to select a proportional location in a trajectory to output, and smoothness. </p>

History

Degree Type

  • Master of Science

Department

  • Computer Science

Campus location

  • West Lafayette

Advisor/Supervisor/Committee Chair

Ahmed H. Qureshi

Additional Committee Member 2

Aniket Bera

Additional Committee Member 3

Clifton Bingham

Usage metrics

    Licence

    Exports

    RefWorks
    BibTeX
    Ref. manager
    Endnote
    DataCite
    NLM
    DC