Ryan - Dissertation FINAL Compressed.pdf (9.99 MB)
EXAMINING THE RELATIONSHIP OF BID DIFFERENCE AND DISADVANTAGED BUSINESS ENTERPRISE PARTICIPATION GOALS IN HIGHWAY CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS
thesisposted on 2020-12-16, 02:20 authored by Robert Thomas RyanRobert Thomas Ryan
This research analyzes over 60,000 awarded highway contracts from 18 states throughout the United States. Analysis was performed on the state and aggregate level. The contracts were awarded from the years 2008 through 2018. Statistical analysis utilizing Pearson's Correlation and Ordinary Least Squares regression for each sample was performed to identify each variables relationship between the budget and awarded values.
The research examined effects of economic indicators, contractor descriptors and yearly/seasonal adjustments These variables included DBE Participation Goal, Number of Bidders, Project Dollar Value, Project Duration, Unemployment Rate, S&P 500 Index, Volatility Index, quarter, and year of project award. The results were examined by using a combination of simple statistical summaries and econometric coefficients called a cost vector.
Summary statistics observed Bid Difference at 8.5% below the Engineer's Estimate. The study observed DBE Participation Goals averaged 3.74% of the value of contracts, with an observed average of 4.5 bidders per contract.
The research determined that 55% of observed states had a positive significant correlation with DBE Participation Goal and Bid Difference. This correlation translated to nearly $80 million in additional cost. In addition, the research determined that all 19 groups in this study had a negative significant correlation with the Number of Bidders. The correlation translated to a savings of nearly $500 million.
- Doctor of Philosophy
- Construction Management Technology
- West Lafayette
Advisor/Supervisor/Committee ChairRandy Rapp
Additional Committee Member 2Sarah Hubbard
Additional Committee Member 3Emad Elwakil
Additional Committee Member 4Mark Shaurette
- Civil engineering not elsewhere classified
- Building construction management and project planning
- Construction engineering
- Social program evaluation
- Public economics - public choice
- Other economics not elsewhere classified
- Transport economics
- Urban and regional economics
- Urban policy
- Engineering practice
- Infrastructure engineering and asset management
- Transport engineering
- Urban and regional planning not elsewhere classified
DBEDOTdisadvantagedestimating equationsconstruction costEconomic Benefit AssociatedEconomic cost analysisFHWAhighway agenciesDepartment of TransportationFraud Risk AssessmentOIGCivil Engineering not elsewhere classifiedBuilding Construction Management and Project PlanningConstruction EngineeringSocial Program EvaluationPublic Economics- Public ChoiceEconomicsTransport EconomicsUrban and Regional EconomicsUrban and Regional Studies (excl. Planning)Urban PolicyEngineering PracticeInfrastructure Engineering and Asset ManagementTransport EngineeringUrban and Regional Planning not elsewhere classified